Showing posts with label slippery slope arguments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label slippery slope arguments. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
Never doubt that slippery slopes can be very very real
A Dutch group is pushing for legalized physician assisted suicide for people over 70 who are "tired of life."
Oddly, part of their argument is that the initial decriminalization of euthanasia in The Netherlands did not lead to any worse consequences: Says Eugène Sutorius (63): "It was thought to be the first step on a slippery slope that would lead the medical profession to lose its integrity. But I have seen nothing of the kind happen."
Apparently, since the first step down the slippery slope didn't lead to any other steps down the slope, we can go ahead and take another few steps down the slope.
At the bottom, at least to my mind, is euthanasia as a treatment for depression.
Oddly, part of their argument is that the initial decriminalization of euthanasia in The Netherlands did not lead to any worse consequences: Says Eugène Sutorius (63): "It was thought to be the first step on a slippery slope that would lead the medical profession to lose its integrity. But I have seen nothing of the kind happen."
Apparently, since the first step down the slippery slope didn't lead to any other steps down the slope, we can go ahead and take another few steps down the slope.
At the bottom, at least to my mind, is euthanasia as a treatment for depression.
Thursday, July 03, 2008
The slippery slope with euthanasia
In Germany, a right-to-die activist has assisted in the suicide of a healthy 79 year old woman. The woman wanted to kill herself to avoid being placed in a nursing home.
This post and the previous one are cross-posted from my online bioethics classes. I try to emphasize to all my classes that slipper slope arguments are sometimes legitimate. They are legitimate if the slope really is slippery and the bottom of the slope really is unacceptable. These are questions you really need to ask yourself when it comes to the euthanasia debate.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
